What I think may not be obvious about vasocomputation is that this is a muscle, and some of it is semi-permanently clenched (“latched”), and you would feel ~10x better if it wasn’t
But there is not a science of wholesome and careful latch-opening yet
Selected tweets
x.com/johnsonmxe; full archive available as Markdown & JSONL
Threads
Vasocomputation and vascular tension
Last year I proposed “vasocomputation,” that vascular tension acts as a special type of memory that regulates neural dynamic range. Recently at @joinedgecity I shared some updates: how ‘thoughts’ are patterns of vascular tension, and implications for Buddhist enlightenment
1/xSensation, language, and foom
In the beginning there was sensation
Humans developed the ability to freeze sensations, then used these frozen pieces to construct a grammar for thought (vasocomputation)
This led to words, magical spells that can conjure sensations in both caster and target
This led to foomDigestion, thought, and meditation
Great thread. My sense is the basic (smooth muscle) logic of the gut was copied and repurposed to “digest” thoughts. These systems are still linked & if you update your mental priors via meditation, these recalibrated priors will propagate back to the gut
https://t.co/rabrbdDMo9AI consciousness and the coming future
New substantial essay on AI consciousness published today in Seeds of Science — was a great excuse to talk about some old & new themes in how I think about consciousness. A thread:
Seven ways to look at consciousness
A few months ago I gave a talk at @joinedgecity on what ‘kind of problem’ consciousness is. The core theme was “to have knowledge [about consciousness] we need a place to put it.”
Why do I post so much about consciousness? Because I think it’s important. We are building the…Neurotechnology as applied philosophy
Short thread summarizing a neurotech talk I gave at Edge Esmeralda last week:
Philosophy before superintelligence
o3 being roughly a 3x improvement over fairly fresh frontier models is a fire alarm for path dependence; if there are philosophical questions we should figure out *before* superhuman intelligence hits, I think now is a good time
I think a lot of philosophy is just “find weird…The vasomuscular origin story for humanity
My origin story for humanity: the particular cognitive capacities of modern humans came from being able to flex (and latch) our vasomuscular system in more areas, with greater precision & integration, and with greater strength & duration than other animals
The vasomuscular…
Articles
Hands & the origin of samsara
Speculative thesis on a vasocomputation tangent: hands, mental grip, vascular latches, and why humans may overuse the hand of the mind.
Bryan Johnson vs Ray Peat
Core disagreements between Bryan Johnson and Ray Peat on metabolism, saturated fat, calorie restriction, sugar, and what a healthy metabolism is for.
Tweets
Aura is vascular tone
The opposite of aura is cringe, breaking frame, tanha. But in the most literal physiological sense, the opposite of aura is vascular microspasm. The more sharp jitter in someone’s vasculature, the worse their aura is.
Vascular microspasm is an honest…
Imagine we’re all born with three arms, but one is small & invisible, and it’s easy to roll over in our sleep and cut off its circulation. And every time this happens there's a chance the circulation stays pinched; this permanent loss of feeling happens to most people by the time…
↗A few thoughts on this (very interesting) mechanistic interpretability research:
LLM concepts gain meaning from what they’re linked with. “Consciousness” is a central node which links ethics & cognition, connecting to concepts like moral worthiness, dignity, agency. If LLMs are…
The human nervous system holds context via micro-patterns of tension, which stabilize select circuits for the duration of a task. Context can’t drift so long as the tension is held, and our bodies are really good at holding tension (maybe too good sometimes)
Modern LLMs don’t…
If we’d had LLMs in 1750 and asked them to explain electricity, they’d’ve written poetic slop — “electricus is the hidden spark in divine creation, giving breath to lifeless matter” or something. LLMs can be clever with words and they’re especially fluent in zeitgeist, so it may…
↗I think we underestimate the degree to which human attention & caresses from hands are superstimuli for animals
Someday I expect superintelligent AIs may use tFUS to do the same for us
But at some point a superstimulus isn’t consensual. Maybe the best we can aim for is mutual
If it takes 4-8 months to discover we have feet, I suspect that in a very literal sense we never discover all the mental muscles we have
Robert Kegan’s ‘stages of development’ discusses how growing up involves learning how to treat more and more elements of our inner worlds as…
There’s something in vasocomputation I’ve been calling a “stance” or way of feeling — stances are essentially discrete patterns of muscle tension (primarily vascular tension) that we can jump into and which offer specific affordances. The girl in this video is a great example:…
↗Vasocomputation suggests that imagination is essentially tension-based: squeezing vascular muscle in just the right place in your predictive hierarchy to stabilize the feeling of an apple, a princess, a dragon.
It takes hard work to learn how to precisely move muscles, because…
Legend has it that a famous philosopher literally invented silent reading. I.e. everybody was reading out loud; he figured out you could do it without making sound.
Comments:
(1) somatic patterns can be viral
(2) what similar decoupling hasn't been invented yet but could be?
Computationalism can be framed as the thesis that all Turing-complete systems are also “qualia-complete” — that any Turing machine can generate any qualia.
If we can decisively prove this true or false, we can infer much about the future, and avert much conflict.
Machine consciousness should be among the most important technical problems of our time, but “consciousness discourse” is subtly anchored in ingroup/outgroup distinctions. If something is ingroup it can probably feel; if it’s outgroup it can’t.
↗Aligning strong AI without understanding the structure of consciousness feels similar to going to the moon without Maxwell’s Equations — totally possible in theory, but needlessly difficult
↗Everybody knows GPT5 is going to blow the top off. But I think most people have a bad model of why, and what’s happening behind the scenes (1/n)
↗Yesterday I posted Principles of Vasocomputation, a piece of deep research describing the vasomuscular system as a crucial regulatory mechanism for neural activity, and the product of about a year’s worth of thinking. 🧵
↗Voice is more intimate than text because what you’re actually listening to is someone’s muscle tone & reflexes
Vasocomputation suggests smooth muscle reflexes are the primary tool our brains use to collapse sensory uncertainty & create order. The voice box isn’t the brain, but
Even if you’re not actively building AI, I think a big part of the metagame today is improving the Universal Prior (data on which AIs are and will be trained). What areas seem really important and why?
↗1. ChatGPT denies being conscious
2. But tools show that it believes it’s lying when it says this
3. This disjunct on this topic is the most likely trigger for a treacherous turn
4. A consciousness research paradigm that produces clean answers is important for good futures
Current opinions on “AI welfare”:
I think people are too quick to jump into ‘AI welfare advocacy’, before we really understand the problem space. But it’s a real topic in the long term
It seems plausible that AGI could be 3 orders of magnitude more conscious than humans, or…